Leveraging Through Software Patents

August 31st, 2008

 

Leveraging through Software Patents

 


 

Patentability of Software

The question of whether software is patentable dates back to the 1970s. The United States Patent and Trade Mark Office (USPTO) historically had been reluctant to grant patents on inventions relating to computer software. Their rationale was that patents could only be granted to processes, machines, and articles of manufacture and compositions of matter. Patents could not be granted to scientific truths or mathematical expressions of it. The USPTO viewed computer programs and inventions containing or relating to computer programs as mere mathematical algorithms, and not processes or machines.

In the 1980s the United States Supreme Court forced the USPTO to change it’s position. Diamond vs. Diehr, decided in 1981, provided the first instance in which the US Supreme Court ordered the USPTO to grant a patent on invention related to Computer Software. In this case, the invention related to a method for determining how rubber should be heated in order to be best “cured”. The invention utilized a computer to calculate and control the heating times for the rubber. However, the invention (as defined by the claims) included not only the computer program, but also included steps to heating rubber, and removing the rubber from the heat. The Supreme Court stated that in this case, the invention was not merely a mathematical algorithm, but was a process of molding rubber, and hence was patentable. This was true even though the only “novel” feature of this invention was the timing process being controlled by the computer.

 

In the early 1990s, the Federal Circuit Court in the United States, which is the highest court for Patent Matters other than the Supreme Court stated that, if the invention utilizes the computer to manipulate numbers that represent concrete, real world values (such as a program that interprets electrocardiograph signals to predict arrhythmia or a program that analyzes seismic measurements), then the inventions relating to those real world concepts is patentable.

In 1995, the U.S.P.T.O. decided it was time to develop guidelines for patent examiners that reflect these recent court decisions. After releasing draft versions of the guidelines for comment, the U.S.P.T.O. adopted guidelines for U.S.P.T.O. examiners to determine when a  software related invention is statutory and therefore patentable.


Patent Protection vis-à-vis Copyright

Bitlaw a comprehensive website on Intellectual Property states that the primary benefit of protecting computer software through the patent system is the strength of protection provided by the patent laws. An owner of a patent may prevent all others from making, using, or selling the patented invention. In connection with software, an issued patent may prevent others from utilizing a certain algorithm (such as the GIF image compression algorithm) without permission, or may prevent others from creating software programs that perform a function in a certain way.

In contrast, copyright law can only prevent the copying of a particular expression of an idea. In connection with computer software, copyright law can be used to prevent the total duplication of a software program, as well as the copying of a portion of software code (both of which are examples of “literal infringement”). In addition, copyright does provide some protection against non-literal infringement, such as the near duplication of screen displays, and the creation of “cloned” software. However, courts have recently been reluctant to interpret copyright protection of computer software in a broad manner. In addition, the basic tenet of copyright law is that copyright will protect only the expression of an idea, and not the idea itself. Consequently, copyright law will not prevent the creation of a competing program that utilizes the same ideas as an existing program.


Need for Patent Protection

In recent years, the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has granted a rapidly increasing number of patents for software-related inventions.

In recent years, the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has granted a rapidly increasing number of patents for software-related inventions. According to the Software Patents Institute in the United States, thousands of “true software patents” are issued every year, covering such areas as business software, expert systems, compiling functions, operating system techniques, and editing functions. At the same time, software technology has continued to advance, using combinations of previous advances in order to create new goods, services, and production processes.

Regardless of one’s opinion on the issue of whether software-related patents are good or bad for society, the fact remains that a rapidly increasing number of software companies are filing software-related patent applications every day. This creates a need for software companies to begin developing programs and procedures to protect their intellectual property through the patent system.

India is emerging as a world leader in the field of software technology. The IT software and services industry in India grossed an annual revenue of Rs. 37,760 crore (US$ 8.26 billion) during 2000-01, according to the annual industry survey released by the National Association of Software and Service Companies (NASSCOM), the apex body of software, e-commerce and IT services industry in India.

Mr. Phiroz Vandrevala, Chairman, NASSCOM while releasing the highlights of Nasscom’s survey said, “the interesting highlight of 2000-01 was that one out of every four global giants, outsourced their `mission critical software requirements’ to India”. Mr. Phiroz Vandrevala further said, “The Indian software industry still requires moving faster on the value chain ladder and getting more involved in strategic consulting, brand management, Research & Development and providing more web based and e-commerce kind of interactive services to the customers”.

Hence the need to protect our Intellectual Property Rights will be more keenly felt once the Indian Software Industry is well on its way to creating a niche as a mature developer of hi-tech software products.


Legal Protection

The Indian Patents Act, 1970 does not explicitly exclude patenting in computer programs. Section 2(1)(j) of the Indian Patents Act, 1970 defines “invention” as any new and useful

i)                    art, process, method or manner of manufacture;

ii)                   machine, apparatus or other article;

iii)                 substance produced by the manufacture

As per the present legal interpretation of the above definition of the invention, the patentable subject matter in addition to being novel and useful, should be about manner of manufacture and it must result in a non-living and tangible thing. From this explanation, it can be inferred that software, as such, in the form of a mathematical algorithm may not be a patentable subject matter as it is not about manner of manufacture and it does not result in a tangible thing.

This situation changes when software is combined with a machine/computer and the machine/computer under the influence of the software, becomes a ‘novel’ machine/computer and this becomes patentable subject matter.

Contrary to popularly held belief that software related patents are not permitted by Indian Patent Office; there are several instances where software related patents have been granted by the Indian Patent Office. One example is the Software related patent no 176178 granted to IBM, USA for “System for Creating an Application Program Package’” by the Indian Patent Office.

Proposed Changes in the Law

The Patents (Second Amendment) Bill, 1999 to the Indian Patents Act, 1970 has been brought out in the light of the TRIPS Agreement and to make the Act a modern, harmonised and user-friendly legislation. However as far as Software Patenting is concerned, the proposed amendments to the act may be considered a retrograde step as it explicitly excludes computer programs from patentability.

This becomes evident if we consider the non-patentable subject matter, which have been specifically included by way of addition to Section 3 (of Indian Patents Act, 1970), which deals with non-patentable inventions. The proposed bill in addition to other non-patentable subject matter excludes “a mathematical or business method or a computer program or algorithms” from patentability.

Once these amendments are affected into the Act, patenting in software will become impossible as compared to the present legal position where the Indian Patents Act does not exclude, explicitly, computer programs from patenting.

Leveraging through Patents

Among companies with patent portfolios, it is a very common practice for one company to offer to cross-license one or more patents of its own when accused of infringing a patent belonging to another company. Through this practice, the patent assets of both companies are increased.

Small and medium software companies can benefit from patenting in software by reaping profits through licensing their patents to bigger corporations. In fact, lack of patent protection makes it easier for bigger corporations to copy ideas from the software developed independently by small and medium software companies.

Thus, software companies should begin evaluating the best internal procedures for identifying potentially patentable ideas and pursuing patent protection for such ideas. Since software-related patent applications are often relatively expensive and time-consuming, appropriate business decisions should also be made to support such an endeavor.

Urgent Needs

While making provisions for patenting in some form in the Indian Patents Act, we must also address the procedural realities of the Indian Patent Office. The facilities at four branches of the Indian Patent Office must be strengthened so that examiners are able to conduct an effective search while deciding the novelty and inventiveness of Software related inventions. The Patent Office should have an Examiner’s Manual, as is done in the USPTO, providing clear cut guidelines regarding patentability of software related inventions. Examiners at four branch offices of the Indian Patent Office should be made fully conversant with the technicalities of software related inventions. Additionally an awareness drive should be vigorously launched to make the software industry fully aware of the issues involved with patenting software in India as well as abroad.

All these needs have to be addressed in right earnest before the nation really benefits from the Great Indian Software Story!

Bibliography

  1. Dr. Ganguli Prabhudda - ‘Gearing Up for Patents - The Indian Scenario’, Orient Longman, 1998
  2. Parulekar Ajit and D’Souza Sarita - Indian Patent Law : Legal and Business Implications , 1st Edition 2006
  3. IPR journal ‘World patent Information’ published by Elsevier Science Limited, UK
  4. Patents Law Manual, 1st Edition, 2005
  5. Website : www.patentmatics.org

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

Patent Era - Need For Innovation

August 30th, 2008

Hundreds and thousands of patents are being filed every month worldwide. There has been an increased activity from all competitors in all technology domains. This results in great technological progress, due to emergence of the new innovations.

All these technical data is presently been accessible through lots of free and commercial knowledge base. As expected in next 10 -20 year, there will be tremendous increase in the patent filing, law suits and a lot more in technology front. It is one of the reason that a lot of outsourcing companies have been evolved in last 3-4 years in India and most of them are providing better and quality services. But most of these companies, not in India, but from allover the globe are using conventional methods of patent searching, analysis and then creation of patent maps.

Thus, there has been great opportunity to enhance and improve the process and method followed by most patent professional, whether in outsourcing companies or in their own IPR cell.

I have been engaged in patent domain from long and always tried to learn new things and create insights. Conventional method of patent searching includes, identification of keywords, concepts and making a query in combination with various search operators (which various from database to database) in consideration of the logic and concept of the invention or technology. But, one thing which most of the searcher skip, is understanding the database behavior. It is very essential to get high and relevant document, if you have clear vision of the database behavior, i.e., when running a query, you should be able to understand what is going on inside the database, before it display results in front of you.

Similarly, there is lots of area in the IP, which needs enhancement to tackle the increased knowledge base in future.

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

VioQuest Pharmaceuticals issued new U.S. patent for Lenocta

August 29th, 2008

VioQuest Pharmaceuticals today announced that the United States Patent and Trademark Office has issued the first patent for the company’s investigational product candidate Lenocta .

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

Patenting of Software- an Insight

August 28th, 2008

That is Software patents refer to patents that could be granted on products or processes (including methods) which include or may include software as a significant or at least necessary part of their implementation, i.e. the form in which they are put in practice (or used) to produce the effect they intend to provide.

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

George Washington Carver’s Inventions

August 27th, 2008

Born as the son of slaves, buried next to Booker T Washington, hundreds of inventions in between - that summarizes the life of George Washington Carver.

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

Next, please: Another patent infringement suit against Nintendo

August 26th, 2008

Rockville, Maryland-based Hillcrest Laboratories has filed a patent infringement suit against Nintendo and its Wiimote controller.

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

Get Patents & Reap Benefits

August 25th, 2008


Today, we are living in the age of information technology & spreading our wings to every aspect of the society. We exchange our information (ideas, techniques, process, and product) to a target group but we never come to know this thing that someone is also targeting our information. So we are much prone to unintentionally leakage of our precious ideas as our information passes through different portals.

It is the human tendency to share their innovative thoughts with their near & dear ones but that proves fatal, in most of the cases, in respect of the that original creation or your property i.e. intellectual property (IP).Most of the people acts indiscreetly & ignorantly which results in jeopardizing the chance of saving their intellectual property i.e. novelty of ideas as they comes under public domain & lose their chance to be protected by the INELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS.

Intellectual property literally means some academic or scholar work. Intellectual property (IP) pertains to any scholar or any original creation of the human intellect; that work can be artistic, literary, technical or scientific creation.

Intellectual property rights mean those rights which are given by the State to the inventor or creator to protect one’s invention or creation for a certain period of time.

Need for intellectual property rights:-

For individual: - IP helps to protect investment of time, money, effort & such other resources of the inventor or creator.

For public:-IP provides a pool of information to the general public since all forms of IP are published in journals & magazines except in case of trade secrets.

For country:-IP provides a mechanism of handling infringement, piracy and unauthorized use & it encourages industrial development & technological advancement which leads to overall economic development of the country.

Bundle of rights:-

IPR are bundle of rights i.e. it includes the various independent rights. Following are the various independent rights for which IPR collectively provides protection:

1. Patent Right(Patent Act,1971 & Patent Rules,2000)

2. Industrial Design(Design Act,)

3. Trademarks (Trademarks Act)

4. Copyright(Copyrights Act)

5. Geographical Indication(Geographical Indication Of Goods Act)

6. Trade secrets(Common Law)

7. Circuit Layout Design(Semiconductor Layout Design Act)

India at International level:-

• The fact that India is a member state of World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), an international organization, responsible for the promotion of the protection of intellectual property throughout the world proves that India has proved its potential & has been acknowledged at international level.

We are here concerned with Patent Law; A patent is an exclusive right granted to inventor or creator of a useful or improved article or a new process of making an article for a specified period of time. After the expiry of the duration the invention becomes part of public domain i.e. everyone can use it. So Patent means monopoly rights of inventor in respect of an invention.

Geographical limits of the patent:-

Patent is granted for a specific invention in a particular country in which an application is made for the same cause. There is no international patent as such though it has acquired an international character. For e.g. a patent granted in India is valid only for India and not in the USA. However, a patent granted in the EPO is valid in all the contracting states recognized by European Patent Organization. The protection so granted in a country / region not only identifies the rights of the creator/ inventor or his assignees, but also enables the right holder to enforce his rights against infringers.

Moreover, several international agreements, treaties & conventions exist to monitor that the inventor/creator are not denied of his/her rights like European Economic Community Treaty(EEC),Patent co-operation Treaty(PCT),European Patent Conventions and Protocols(EPC),Community Patent Convention and Protocols(CPC) resulting in a common patent office for granting common patents applicable to the member countries.

What can be patented?

Only inventions can be patented.Sec.2 (1) (j) defines invention as an invention means a new product or a new process involving an inventive step & capable of industrial application. Invention includes within its scope any new & useful improvements of any manner of manufacture, article or substance whether patented or not but such improvement must qualify independently to satisfy the pre-requisites of the patent i.e. novelty, inventive step & capable of industrial application.

Who may apply for patent?

An application for a patent may be made by inventor, either alone or jointly with another, or his/their assignee, legal representative of deceased inventor or assignee are entitled to apply. For e.g. If a person invents a new product or process & unfortunately soon after that he dies then his legal heirs can or any person authorized by him before his death can apply for patent.

Term & date of patent:-

Term of every patent will be from 20 years from the date of filling of patent application & date of patent is the date on which the application for patent is filed, irrespective of the fact whether it is filed with provisional or complete application. To keep the patent in force renewal fee is to be paid every year. The first renewal fee is payable for the third year of the patent’s life & must be paid before the patent’s second anniversary. Term of patent can’t be extended beyond the specified term of patent.

Where a patent application should be filed?

The Indian Patent Office has its head office at Kolkata, which has three branch offices located at Mumbai, Chennai and Delhi. The Controller General heads the Patent Office and each branch has a Controller as its head. In case of an Indian applicant, the patent application must be filed at the patent office under whose jurisdiction the applicant’s has his place of work, or place of residence or place where he conduct business from.

For e.g. if an applicant provides a Chandigarh based address, the application must be filed at the Delhi Patent Office. In case of foreign applicant/s, the jurisdiction in which the patent application is filed would be based on the address for services of the applicant’s agent. For e.g. if the address for services for foreign applicant is based at Bangalore, the patent application must be filed at the Chennai Patent Office.

What are the rights given to the patentee?

The patentee (i.e. an applicant who has been granted a patent) has the exclusive right to prevent unauthorized third parties from making, using, offering for sale, selling or importing the patented product or process in India.

Patent information centre:-

Patent Information Centre (PIC) has been set up in 20 states & is further expanding in other states. Patent information centre provides information regarding the techniqulities & procedure laid down by the government to get a patent. One can get all the information regarding the filing of the patent application & further procedure up till the patent is not granted. The centre provides general precaution for the applicant before & after applying for a patent. The most common mistake which an applicant often does is to publish their invention in newspaper or scientific & technical journals, before applying for patents. Publication of an invention, even by the inventor himself, would (except under certain rare circumstances) constitute a bar for the subsequent patenting of it. Similarly, the use of the invention in public, or the commercial use of the invention in public or even in secrecy, prior to the date of the patent would be a fatal objection to the grant of the patent. However the secret working of the invention by way of reasonable trial or experiment, or the disclosure of the invention to other confidentially may not result into loss of novelty.

Another mistake, which is frequently made by the inventors, is to wait until their inventions are fully developed for commercial working, before applying for the patents. Delay in making application for a patent involves certain risks. so it is advisable to apply for the patent as soon as one’s invention get a physical appearance with 3-D drawings sheets depicting the whole model.

Incentives for obtaining patents:-

An innovative industry can gain competitive advantage in the market if it develops the necessary expertise and skills in developing and manufacturing new products, which are patented. For example, the advantage of a three year excise duty exemption or exemption from Drugs Price Control Order may translate into reserves / income which may offset the cost towards R&D. In order to promote R&D and innovation in Indian industries, Government of India provides a number of fiscal incentives and support measures to industries. Some of them are following:-

• Excise duty waiver on the patented article for a period of 3 years from the date of commencement of commercial production provided that such products be designed &developed by wholly owned Indian companies.

• Exemption from drug price control for a period of 5 years from the date of commencement of commercial production provided that they are produced from the basic stage by a process of manufacture developed by the unit through its own R&D efforts.

• Weighted tax deduction @ 150% on R&D expenditure is available to companies engaged in the business of biotechnology, or the business of manufacture or production of drugs, pharmaceuticals, electronic equipment, computers, telecommunication equipment, chemicals and manufacture of aircraft and helicopters. The expenditure on scientific research in relation to drugs and pharmaceuticals shall include expenditure incurred on clinical trials of drugs, obtaining approval from the regulatory authority under any Central, State or provincial Act and the filing of a patent application in India.

• Depreciation allowance at a higher rate is available in respect of plant and machinery installed for manufacturing goods based on indigenous technology developed in recognized in-house R&D units, Government R&D institutions, national laboratories and Scientific and Industrial Organizations (SIRO). The present rate of depreciation for plant and machinery is 40% as against 25% for other plants and machinery.

• Income tax exemption:-Under Section 35(1)(i) of the Income Tax Act 1961, the revenue expenditure on scientific research, by recognized R&D units, on activities related to the business of the company is allowed full deduction. Under Section 35(1)(iv) expenses of capital nature could be deducted totally from the income of the year in which the expenses have been incurred. Section 35(2AA) of the IT Act 1961 provides for a weighted tax deduction of 125% for expenses on sponsoring research programmes at National laboratories functioning under ICAR, CSIR, ICMR, DRDO, Department of Biotechnology, Department of Atomic Energy, Department of Electronics; IIT and universities.

For more information locate at:-http:/Ipindia.nic.in. Or e-mail at: pisnag@nag.mah.nic.in/pisnagpur@satyam.net.in

For further inquiries e-mail writer at: - kamal_417@yahoo.com, kamdahiya@gmail.com

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

Patent Landscaping

August 24th, 2008

New innovation through research is becoming more and more expensive, mostly in case of pharmaceutical industries. If after investing lots on money and efforts, one cannot commercialize their invention due to unforeseen problems with third party patents, then it is a high loss. Thus to ease the commercialization of new research innovations, most innovative and research-driven companies have started outsourcing patent landscaping studies for their future research plans.

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

The State of Play in an “Architecture” Fight: Printer Cartridges

August 23rd, 2008

There’s also a long-standing war between printer makers and third-party cartridge companies that sell cheap knockoff ink packs.

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

Get Patents & Reap Benefits

August 22nd, 2008


Today, we are living in the age of information technology & spreading our wings to every aspect of the society. We exchange our information (ideas, techniques, process, and product) to a target group but we never come to know this thing that someone is also targeting our information. So we are much prone to unintentionally leakage of our precious ideas as our information passes through different portals.

It is the human tendency to share their innovative thoughts with their near & dear ones but that proves fatal, in most of the cases, in respect of the that original creation or your property i.e. intellectual property (IP).Most of the people acts indiscreetly & ignorantly which results in jeopardizing the chance of saving their intellectual property i.e. novelty of ideas as they comes under public domain & lose their chance to be protected by the INELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS.

Intellectual property literally means some academic or scholar work. Intellectual property (IP) pertains to any scholar or any original creation of the human intellect; that work can be artistic, literary, technical or scientific creation.

Intellectual property rights mean those rights which are given by the State to the inventor or creator to protect one’s invention or creation for a certain period of time.

Need for intellectual property rights:-

For individual: - IP helps to protect investment of time, money, effort & such other resources of the inventor or creator.

For public:-IP provides a pool of information to the general public since all forms of IP are published in journals & magazines except in case of trade secrets.

For country:-IP provides a mechanism of handling infringement, piracy and unauthorized use & it encourages industrial development & technological advancement which leads to overall economic development of the country.

Bundle of rights:-

IPR are bundle of rights i.e. it includes the various independent rights. Following are the various independent rights for which IPR collectively provides protection:

1. Patent Right(Patent Act,1971 & Patent Rules,2000)

2. Industrial Design(Design Act,)

3. Trademarks (Trademarks Act)

4. Copyright(Copyrights Act)

5. Geographical Indication(Geographical Indication Of Goods Act)

6. Trade secrets(Common Law)

7. Circuit Layout Design(Semiconductor Layout Design Act)

India at International level:-

• The fact that India is a member state of World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), an international organization, responsible for the promotion of the protection of intellectual property throughout the world proves that India has proved its potential & has been acknowledged at international level.

We are here concerned with Patent Law; A patent is an exclusive right granted to inventor or creator of a useful or improved article or a new process of making an article for a specified period of time. After the expiry of the duration the invention becomes part of public domain i.e. everyone can use it. So Patent means monopoly rights of inventor in respect of an invention.

Geographical limits of the patent:-

Patent is granted for a specific invention in a particular country in which an application is made for the same cause. There is no international patent as such though it has acquired an international character. For e.g. a patent granted in India is valid only for India and not in the USA. However, a patent granted in the EPO is valid in all the contracting states recognized by European Patent Organization. The protection so granted in a country / region not only identifies the rights of the creator/ inventor or his assignees, but also enables the right holder to enforce his rights against infringers.

Moreover, several international agreements, treaties & conventions exist to monitor that the inventor/creator are not denied of his/her rights like European Economic Community Treaty(EEC),Patent co-operation Treaty(PCT),European Patent Conventions and Protocols(EPC),Community Patent Convention and Protocols(CPC) resulting in a common patent office for granting common patents applicable to the member countries.

What can be patented?

Only inventions can be patented.Sec.2 (1) (j) defines invention as an invention means a new product or a new process involving an inventive step & capable of industrial application. Invention includes within its scope any new & useful improvements of any manner of manufacture, article or substance whether patented or not but such improvement must qualify independently to satisfy the pre-requisites of the patent i.e. novelty, inventive step & capable of industrial application.

Who may apply for patent?

An application for a patent may be made by inventor, either alone or jointly with another, or his/their assignee, legal representative of deceased inventor or assignee are entitled to apply. For e.g. If a person invents a new product or process & unfortunately soon after that he dies then his legal heirs can or any person authorized by him before his death can apply for patent.

Term & date of patent:-

Term of every patent will be from 20 years from the date of filling of patent application & date of patent is the date on which the application for patent is filed, irrespective of the fact whether it is filed with provisional or complete application. To keep the patent in force renewal fee is to be paid every year. The first renewal fee is payable for the third year of the patent’s life & must be paid before the patent’s second anniversary. Term of patent can’t be extended beyond the specified term of patent.

Where a patent application should be filed?

The Indian Patent Office has its head office at Kolkata, which has three branch offices located at Mumbai, Chennai and Delhi. The Controller General heads the Patent Office and each branch has a Controller as its head. In case of an Indian applicant, the patent application must be filed at the patent office under whose jurisdiction the applicant’s has his place of work, or place of residence or place where he conduct business from.

For e.g. if an applicant provides a Chandigarh based address, the application must be filed at the Delhi Patent Office. In case of foreign applicant/s, the jurisdiction in which the patent application is filed would be based on the address for services of the applicant’s agent. For e.g. if the address for services for foreign applicant is based at Bangalore, the patent application must be filed at the Chennai Patent Office.

What are the rights given to the patentee?

The patentee (i.e. an applicant who has been granted a patent) has the exclusive right to prevent unauthorized third parties from making, using, offering for sale, selling or importing the patented product or process in India.

Patent information centre:-

Patent Information Centre (PIC) has been set up in 20 states & is further expanding in other states. Patent information centre provides information regarding the techniqulities & procedure laid down by the government to get a patent. One can get all the information regarding the filing of the patent application & further procedure up till the patent is not granted. The centre provides general precaution for the applicant before & after applying for a patent. The most common mistake which an applicant often does is to publish their invention in newspaper or scientific & technical journals, before applying for patents. Publication of an invention, even by the inventor himself, would (except under certain rare circumstances) constitute a bar for the subsequent patenting of it. Similarly, the use of the invention in public, or the commercial use of the invention in public or even in secrecy, prior to the date of the patent would be a fatal objection to the grant of the patent. However the secret working of the invention by way of reasonable trial or experiment, or the disclosure of the invention to other confidentially may not result into loss of novelty.

Another mistake, which is frequently made by the inventors, is to wait until their inventions are fully developed for commercial working, before applying for the patents. Delay in making application for a patent involves certain risks. so it is advisable to apply for the patent as soon as one’s invention get a physical appearance with 3-D drawings sheets depicting the whole model.

Incentives for obtaining patents:-

An innovative industry can gain competitive advantage in the market if it develops the necessary expertise and skills in developing and manufacturing new products, which are patented. For example, the advantage of a three year excise duty exemption or exemption from Drugs Price Control Order may translate into reserves / income which may offset the cost towards R&D. In order to promote R&D and innovation in Indian industries, Government of India provides a number of fiscal incentives and support measures to industries. Some of them are following:-

• Excise duty waiver on the patented article for a period of 3 years from the date of commencement of commercial production provided that such products be designed &developed by wholly owned Indian companies.

• Exemption from drug price control for a period of 5 years from the date of commencement of commercial production provided that they are produced from the basic stage by a process of manufacture developed by the unit through its own R&D efforts.

• Weighted tax deduction @ 150% on R&D expenditure is available to companies engaged in the business of biotechnology, or the business of manufacture or production of drugs, pharmaceuticals, electronic equipment, computers, telecommunication equipment, chemicals and manufacture of aircraft and helicopters. The expenditure on scientific research in relation to drugs and pharmaceuticals shall include expenditure incurred on clinical trials of drugs, obtaining approval from the regulatory authority under any Central, State or provincial Act and the filing of a patent application in India.

• Depreciation allowance at a higher rate is available in respect of plant and machinery installed for manufacturing goods based on indigenous technology developed in recognized in-house R&D units, Government R&D institutions, national laboratories and Scientific and Industrial Organizations (SIRO). The present rate of depreciation for plant and machinery is 40% as against 25% for other plants and machinery.

• Income tax exemption:-Under Section 35(1)(i) of the Income Tax Act 1961, the revenue expenditure on scientific research, by recognized R&D units, on activities related to the business of the company is allowed full deduction. Under Section 35(1)(iv) expenses of capital nature could be deducted totally from the income of the year in which the expenses have been incurred. Section 35(2AA) of the IT Act 1961 provides for a weighted tax deduction of 125% for expenses on sponsoring research programmes at National laboratories functioning under ICAR, CSIR, ICMR, DRDO, Department of Biotechnology, Department of Atomic Energy, Department of Electronics; IIT and universities.

For more information locate at:-http:/Ipindia.nic.in. Or e-mail at: pisnag@nag.mah.nic.in/pisnagpur@satyam.net.in

For further inquiries e-mail writer at: - kamal_417@yahoo.com, kamdahiya@gmail.com

Read more

Posted in Guide of Patent Protection | No Comments »

« Previous Entries